| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
 James Schamus | Crew | Production | Producer |
 Nathan Larson | Crew | Sound | Original Music Composer |
Sam Petty | Crew | Sound | Sound Designer |
Scott Macaulay | Crew | Production | Producer |
Tracy McKnight | Crew | Sound | Music Supervisor |
Mitch Dickman | Crew | Production | Co-Producer |
Davis Coombe | Crew | Editing | Editor |
 Kitty Green | Crew | Directing | Director, Producer, Writer |
Michael Latham | Crew | Camera | Director of Photography |
Rita Walsh | Crew | Production | Associate Producer |
Avy Eschenasy | Crew | Production | Executive Producer |
Joe Pirro | Crew | Production | Associate Producer |
Leah Popple | Crew | Art | Production Design |
Catharina Schurenberg | Crew | Costume & Make-Up | Costume Design |
Jonathan Mussman | Crew | Production | Production Executive |
Jennifer Dong | Crew | Production | Executive Producer |
Figo Li | Crew | Production | Executive Producer |
Chuck Fiorella | Cast | John Ramsey / John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
 Joe Bocian | Cast | John Mark Karr Auditionee / Himself | |
 Dan Davidson | Cast | Actor | Police Chief Auditionee / Himself |
 Laura Lee | Cast | Actress | Patsy Ramsey / Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself |
Lynne Jordan | Cast | Psychologist | |
 Tamara Hutchins | Cast | Actress | Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself |
Amy Dowd | Cast | Patsy Ramsey / Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
 Hannah Cagwin | Cast | Actress | JonBenet Ramsey / JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee / Herself |
Aeona Cruz | Cast | Actress | JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee / Herself |
Liv Bagley | Cast | JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Shylee Sagle | Cast | JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Danika Toolson | Cast | JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Nicole Hamilton | Cast | JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee / JonBenet Ramsey Dance Double / Herself | |
Emma Winslow | Cast | JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Elle Walker | Cast | JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Jerry Cortese | Cast | Officer French / John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Kit Thompson | Cast | Patsy Ramsey / Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Teresa Cocas | Cast | Patsy Ramsey / Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Stephanie Federico | Cast | Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Deb Hultgren | Cast | Patsy Ramsey / Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Ronda Belser | Cast | Patsy Ramsey / Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Dorinda Dercar | Cast | Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Carolyn Strauss | Cast | Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Aspen Rader | Cast | Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
J. Michael Sterling | Cast | Officer Veitch / John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Hack Hyland | Cast | John Ramsey / John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Gary Foster | Cast | John Ramsey / John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Ed Hickok | Cast | John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
 Gary J. Neuger | Cast | John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Robert Toomey | Cast | John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Mark Taylor | Cast | John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Jay Benedict Brown | Cast | John Ramsey / John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Rand Moritzky | Cast | Coroner | |
William Tidwell | Cast | Police Chief / Police Chief Auditionee / Himself | |
Blake Curton | Cast | Police Chief Auditionee / Himself | |
Rj Clay | Cast | Police Chief Auditionee / Himself | |
John Bronson | Cast | Police Chief Auditionee / Himself | |
Dale Strom | Cast | Reporter / Police Chief Auditionee / Himself | |
Carlos Martinez | Cast | Police Chief Auditionee / Himself | |
Michael Kennedy | Cast | Actor | Police Chief Auditionee / Himself |
Timothy Ackerman | Cast | Police Chief Auditionee / Himself | |
Casey Lloyd | Cast | Police Chief Auditionee / Himself | |
Mark Canjar | Cast | Police Chief Auditionee / Himself | |
Marian Rothschild | Cast | Patsy Ramsey / Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Suzanne Yazzie | Cast | Patsy Ramsey / Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Chris Mueser | Cast | John Ramsey / John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Kaye Taavialma | Cast | Patsy Ramsey / Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Jacqui Pugh | Cast | Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Paul Crumby | Cast | John Ramsey / John Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Ryan Haskell | Cast | Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Taylor Hollenback | Cast | Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Jase Wiedeman | Cast | Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Tre Penna | Cast | Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Riley Hastings | Cast | Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Sean Legg | Cast | Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Luca Rodriguez | Cast | Burke Ramsey / Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Joe Brienza | Cast | Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
 Gavin White | Cast | Actor | Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself |
Noah Isakson | Cast | Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Robby Hanbery | Cast | Burke Ramsey Auditionee / Himself | |
Kristina Jones | Cast | Patsy Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Jim Beck | Cast | Santa Claus Auditionee / Himself | |
John Chilson | Cast | Santa Claus Auditionee / Himself | |
Johnny Claus | Cast | Santa Claus Auditionee / Himself | |
Randy Schriever | Cast | Santa Claus / Santa Claus Auditionee / Himself | |
James Lewis | Cast | Santa Claus Auditionee / Himself | |
Gary Woods | Cast | Funeral Director | |
Kaydence Lucero | Cast | JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee / Herself | |
Dixon White | Cast | John Mark Karr / John Mark Karr Auditionee / Himself | |
Steven Scott | Cast | John Mark Karr Auditionee / Himself | |
| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) |
