| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
 Chad Davidson | Crew | Camera | Director of Photography |
 Joshua Zeman | Crew | Directing | Director, Producer, Writer |
Zachary Mortensen | Crew | Production | Executive Producer |
 Barbara Brancaccio | Crew | Directing | Director, Producer |
Jeffrey Kusama-Hinte | Crew | Production | Executive Producer |
Evan Krauss | Crew | Production | Co-Executive Producer |
 Alex Lasarenko | Crew | Sound | Original Music Composer |
Maria Elena Lopez-Frank | Crew | Production | Associate Producer |
 Jonathan Gray | Crew | Production | Co-Executive Producer |
Todd Tiberi | Crew | Production | Associate Producer |
Corbin Day | Crew | Production | Associate Producer |
Ernie Anastos | Cast | Actor | Himself - Reporter (archive footage) |
Joshua Zeman | Cast | Actor | Himself |
Judah Lazarus | Cast | Himself | |
Barbara Brancaccio | Cast | Actress | Herself |
Greg Cusick | Cast | Himself | |
 Geraldo Rivera | Cast | Actor | Himself - Reporter (archive footage) |
Sean Hughes | Cast | Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother (archive footage) | |
Ken Schweiger | Cast | Himself - Jennifer Schweiger's Father | |
Leonard D'Alessandro | Cast | Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD | |
Andre Rand | Cast | Himself - Suspect | |
Dorothy D'Eletto | Cast | Herself - Archivist & Researcher | |
Rita Dimartino | Cast | Herself - Aunt of Alice Pereira | |
Thomas Micol | Cast | Himself - Staten Island Resident | |
Steve Bogen | Cast | Himself | |
Jack Whitford | Cast | Himself - Stapleton Civilian Observation Patrol | |
David Navarro | Cast | Himself - Former Newscaster | |
Kristine Gosling | Cast | Herself - Det. Sgt. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPD | |
Charlie Cutugno | Cast | Himself | |
Patricia Caridad | Cast | Herself | |
Thomas Jenkins | Cast | Himself - Staten Island Resident | |
Brett Straniere | Cast | Himself | |
Carolyn Muskett | Cast | Herself | |
Devin Cutugno | Cast | Himself - Donna's Son | |
Robert Caruso | Cast | Himself | |
Theresa Doyle | Cast | Herself - Searcher for Jennifer | |
Robert Foster | Cast | Himself | |
Karen Schweiger | Cast | Herself - Jennifer Schweiger's Mother | |
Frank Marchionne | Cast | Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD | |
Marla Dziergowski | Cast | Herself | |
Ralph Aquino | Cast | Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD | |
Jim Callaghan | Cast | Himself - Former Editor, Staten Island Eagle | |
Marie Piazza | Cast | Herself | |
Bob Graham | Cast | Himself - Acquaintance of Rand | |
Larry Simon | Cast | Himself - Defense Attorney for Andre Rand | |
Ed Armstrong | Cast | Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother | |
Bill Ellis | Cast | Actor | Himself - Professor of Folklore, Penn State |
Donna Cutugno | Cast | Herself - Founder, Friends of Jennifer | |
Bobby Jensen | Cast | Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD | |
Jim Dolan | Cast | Himself - Reporter (archive footage) | |
Peter Hughes | Cast | Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Father | |
Holly Cederholm | Cast | Herself - Holly Ann Hughes's Mother | |
John O'Brien | Cast | Himself - Reporter, Staten Island Advance | |
Duane Felton | Cast | Himself - Defense Attorney for Andre Rand | |
William L. Murphy | Cast | Himself - Staten Island District Attorney | |
Trina Cutugno | Cast | Herself - Donna's Daughter | |
Jimmy Rassias | Cast | Himself - Former Clerk, Port Richmond Deli | |
Frank Saez | Cast | Himself - Ret. Det. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPD | |
Frances Auriti | Cast | Herself - Searcher, Friend of Jennifer | |
Tracy Begley | Cast | Herself - Searcher, Friend of Jennifer | |
Glenn Chapman | Cast | Himself - Former Reporter, Staten Island Advance | |
Martha Hinton | Cast | Herself - Witness | |
Tanya Goodson | Cast | Herself - Witness | |
Charles G. Muskett Sr. | Cast | Himself - Former Minister | |
Daniel M. Donovan Jr. | Cast | Himself - District Attorney for Richmond County | |
Melissa Grace | Cast | Herself | |
Bruce Meyersen | Cast | Himself | |
Lorraine Shanley | Cast | Herself | |
Luis Rivera | Cast | Himself - Retired Canine Officer, NYPD | |
| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) |
