Perfectly acceptable live action remake tat isn't as soul-killing as Lion King nor as hopelessly banal as Dumbo. The movements of the mouths didn't put me off as I've seen far worse in the sub-genre of talking dog cgi cinema. Sincerely no clue why it's getting so much hate.

It's fine. The animation looks great. The story is exactly what you expect.

Needless? Yes. Enjoyable? Also, yes.

I'm not entirely sure 'Lady and the Tramp' was a film that needed remaking but here we are. This 2019 production is solid. I like the way it is shot and brought to life. It's rewritten in a few parts, to mostly positive effect - though the original film is still, by a fair distance, best.

I wouldn't say the cast are anything exceptional but they do what's needed. Tessa Thompson and Justin Theroux give good performances as Lady and Tramp respectively, while Adrian Martinez's Elliot is probably the character I'll remember most - away from the two dogs, of course. Janelle Monáe, Sam Elliott and Yvette Nicole Brown are decent too; even if it is difficult to picture the latter as a baddie.

They get rid of the "The Siamese Cat Song", though the replacement tune is actually fairly good. The other songs, like "La La Lu", remain but are obviously tinkered. The run time is longer, which I don't think was nessacary but they fill it well enough.

Solid attempt.

This film is so adorable. The dogs in it are really cute, and I love the fact that they trained rescue dogs to play the roles. It's a bit jarring seeing no reference to racism in the 1910s period setting though. They could have done something very interesting there, given that Lady's owners are a mixed race couple. And speaking of her owners, once they have the baby they kind of overplay their negligence towards her. I mean they don't even take the poor dog for a walk!

I know they make a point in the screenplay of them apologising to Lady for their poor post-baby treatment, but it still doesn't sit right for me. Especially when the story ends with them adopting Tramp. This couple are clearly not fit to own a dog.

Overall though, it's a fun addition to the Disney Plus exclusive content and definitely one you should watch if you're a dog lover like me.

It was a great movie. It should have been released theatrically.

A fun and light-hearted reimagining with convincing and cute dogs that doesn't recapture the magic of the original. Great CGI work too.
Makes me want a cocker spaniel and I love the diversity in the cast.

Great remake and glad to see it give opportunities to other actors who are not white for this rendition.

My Score 7/10.

Sam Elliott as Trusty was the best part of this adorable live action remake of an animated Disney classic. The animated Lady and the Tramp has been a lifelong favorite movie of mine, and I wasn’t too sure about this one doing it any justice or feeling at all absorbed in it (because of the whole real animals “speaking” aspect. But the effects were well done, all of the actors were well cast, and my dog loving 7-year old loved watching the dogs be cute, especially parts with puppies. Unlike numerous other kid’s movies that shall remain unnamed here, I would have no issue watching this again if my kiddo wanted more cute puppy movie time. Solid 7 (Good) rating from me!

You've seen it all before - literally, its the same film as the animated original. Still, if you liked that you might like this, though like many of the recent Disney remakes, it will never be considered a classic.

A classic is always a classic, watched the original first time 20 years ago was so good to view the new one

I loved the original and I loved this version.... it’s the story.... so sweet...

I kinda loved it better than the original! Glad that they changed the cats from that weird asian stereotype and loved seeing POC in it - contrary to a comment I've seen here, I don't think they should've done anything about racism just because they were a mixed couple in the 1920's or something. I'm not a POC but as I've read a black person say once, sometimes it's nice to just see POC without having a racism storyline to it. We have plenty of films about that, POC need films where their tragedies aren't glorified and it was so sweet seeing that mixed couple just being and other POC in the movie. Anyways, absolutely loved it!