Type in any movie or show to find where you can watch it, or type a person's name.

User Reviews for: Mona Lisa Smile

aneemelia
9/10  9 years ago
I really enjoyed watching this movie. There were many great scenes, many great lines, and development in relationships. Somethings were a little cliche, but when looking at everything I actually liked about the movie, they become less of a problem, and not that noticable to me. There are parts I wished I could get to know more about, some of the relationships which were ended too quickly, so that I didn't get real closure as a viewer, but overall this is a movie I would recommend to any girl, or for that matter, boy, who wants to think a little about the gender roles in our society, how far it as come. And also, to do some evaluation while watching or after, if these gender roles still apply in some cases, and how we're still obsessed with fitting into what society wants us to be. No matter what gender, there's more equality between sexes now, but both men and women (and those who are genderfluid/or don't conform to any gender) still have a role that we play, maybe more subconsciously than we'd like to admit. But when given the chance, like after watching this movie, we can look closer at our own society today, and see if there are changes we need to make. This is truly an inspirational art, if you're just open to finding out what the movie can mean to you.

Of course critics will slaughter it, because it both has cliches and can be rather odd(not too hollywood) at times, but these are the ones who don't have the time, or give their time, to find out what something might mean to them. Everything that we experience has the chance to educate us in some way, to expand our thinking, if we just let it. I pity those who don't give things a chance, and judge without thinking something through, no matter it be a movie or a person.

Overall, just watch it if you're an openminded spirit like me, if you're someone who don't like to think for themselves however, this movie will bore you, because it tries to make YOU think.
Like  -  Dislike  -  30
Please use spoiler tags:[spoiler] text [/spoiler]
Halsyone
6/10  3 years ago
Maybe I can never be satisfied, but though I enjoyed this movie, it left me feeling disappointed and frustrated.

The first half of _Mona Lisa Smile_ - though not without its flaws (the only living lesbian character mentioned is fired a few minutes in after only a few lines; the only non-white character, I think, was the black worker at the very beginning) - was thrilling. It felt like one of those academia movies about boys and men. I liked it enough, at least, to overlook how unrealistically awful all the students were to each other - of course women are catty, that's a given.
The high point of the movie, for me, was the scene in which Katherine Watson gives a lecture based on the way ads represent women and what the point of women's education is, and then blow up at her colleagues, calling the college a finishing school in disguise. That was wonderful.

Unfortunately, that's also where it all went downhill. After the brilliance of that scene, the movie suddenly stopped attempting anything close to critical thinking. Every choice is valid, and discussing how much of a "choice" it really is if everything in your life pushes you to it... well, who cares about that? The girls all get married or will get married or let the biggest part of their lives revolve around men; Katherine Watson disappear in far-off Europe; all is as it should be. Ultimately, this movie about women is still very much about men. The only one of her colleagues that Katherine really gets to know is the male Italian teacher who abuses his students (cute). Her female colleagues are either nameless, fired, or depicted as pathetic. The students all "freely" "choose" to prioritise men. Even in the best moments, when Katherine strives for some kind of liberation for women, it's always turned toward men, and not toward being with other women, putting women first. It's significant that not one female artist is named, in a movie about women who study art.

All in all, it's a braver movie than many, but unsurprisingly drops the ball. We wouldn't want to be extremists, right?
Like  -  Dislike  -  3
Please use spoiler tags:[spoiler] text [/spoiler]
Reply by dogg724
3 years ago
@halsyone You understand the era it's depicting, right? Do you base the enjoyability or value of a movie for it's ability to check representation boxes? You think these women are unrealistically awful to each other? How old are you?<br /> <br /> "Ultimately, this movie about women is still very much about men."<br /> <br /> Or the interplay of both at that era at that particular school?<br /> <br /> "We wouldn't want to be extremists, right?"<br /> <br /> What?<br /> <br /> I find nearly everything you've stated immensely confusing.
Reply  -  Like  -  Deslike  -  00

Please use spoiler tags:[spoiler] text [/spoiler]
Reply by Halsyone
3 years ago
@dogg724 Yeah, I can tell you find it all very confusing. I'll try to put it in simpler terms.<br /> <br /> This movie might be depicting a "long-gone" era, but it was made in 2003 by people alive in 2003 for a 2003 audience, and therefore it says a lot about people in 2003. Moreover, we all watch movies with our own sensibilities, and it's ludicrous to think that it's possible (or even desirable) to watch a movie (or read a book, for that matter) with the same value system we assume people had when it was made. <br /> <br /> My review had absolutely nothing to do with female characters being "unrealistically awful to each other". This is a story someone made up, not a documentary. And the people who created that story _chose_ to make nearly every one of those female characters revolve around men. I take issue with that fact, from a movie ostensibly about women's lives and struggles.<br /> <br /> But please, keep telling me, a woman, how awful women can "realistically" be to each other. Without actually engaging with the content of my comment, of course - that's so much more stimulating.
Reply  -  Like  -  Deslike  -  00

Please use spoiler tags:[spoiler] text [/spoiler]
Reply by dogg724
2 years ago
@halsyone you either don't recall what you said in your own review, or you're making an incredible effort to pretend like what you and I both quoted from what you said says something wildly different than it does. Either way, it feels dishonest and disingenuous.<br /> <br /> The movie, maybe, is saying something very instructive and informative that women's lives were all about men back then and it wasn't a good thing. Does that feel like a foreign proposition to you? I quoted you, you quoted you, then you accused me of not engaging with your comment? You make less sense the more you speak, so I'm excited for whatever is coming next.<br /> <br /> Simply, instead of engaging with the story given, you're upset you didn't see one you would have preferred. You played out the same pattern in your response to me lol. You'll start making sense when you stick with criticizing what's actually there verses your confused and disappointed feelings.
Reply  -  Like  -  Deslike  -  00

Please use spoiler tags:[spoiler] text [/spoiler]
Back to Top