Premise - 15/20 - Two people on the opposite sides of a political debate actually get along, talk, and don't really try to change each other? I had to see this for myself.
Cast/characters - 17/20 - Kate Mara is unbelievably hot in this movie. I don't mind saying I thought Elliot Page was also pretty hot back when she was Ellen Page. A little skinny, maybe, but her passion in this movie makes her hot. As Lucy and Mercy, I thought they were wonderful as people who have reasons outside religion or money to believe in something. The other cast could have been anyone, but each of them did their jobs. The guy Weldon was hard to figure out.
Story - 18/20 - Fantastic arc of a story, from black and white sides to finding gray areas where we can empathize with each other if we make that attempt. Just in case you think I'm in it for the art of the cinema, I came for the sex scenes and they didn't disappoint. Then I became pleasantly surprised by a good story and a sweet ending.
Dialogue - 16/20 - Their discussions were very strong to help develop their characters.
World-building - 16/20 - An interesting part was that no matter where they all were, it was the same people doing the same things. What really worked for me was the fact you see the lives of traveling protesters, and how they live their lives in order to make that happen.