Let me start by saying that I really loved the previous three 'Pirates' films. They were a great mix of treasure-seaking adventure and humor, action and romance. They were the Indiana Jones of this generation.

While this fourth 'Pirates' movie has all the ingredients of the previous ones (with the addition of Blackbeard and man-eating mermaids), and even looks and sounds just as great, it seems like the magic is gone. For some reason I couldn't get involved in the story or the characters (old or new). Both the story and the acting seemed contrived (even more than before), meaningless and empty. Instead of the two hours of high-quality entertainment I expected, I got mediocre. Not bad, but I've come to expect more of it.

Unfortunately, this movie is easily forgettable. Not up to par with the previous installments. Let's hope they get their groove back in the next one.

A disappointment to the franchise in my eyes. I still want to see the new one, but the first 3 are way above this one. Think the lack of Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley effects it majorly.

Not a fan of hers

I for one still enjoyed it. Jack holds his own as expected.

Still a B+ movie to me.

I'd rather swab the deck than rewatch this

Just as great as the others, I don't even miss the original cast.

Worth the watch but not amazing.

This movie should have never happened. There's none of that feel from the previous movies left. Just like Draackje wrote I believe the magic left with the director. I had very low expectations and somehow I was still disappointed. And this is from a guy who loved the first three. Such fond memories all crushed since they just had to make a fourth movie.

they should stop. now.

Pirates of the Caribbean
The Curse of the Black Pearl (2003) https://trakt.tv/movies/pirates-of-the-caribbean-the-curse-of-the-black-pearl-2003
Dead Man's Chest (2006) https://trakt.tv/movies/pirates-of-the-caribbean-dead-man-s-chest-2006
At World's End (2007) https://trakt.tv/movies/pirates-of-the-caribbean-at-world-s-end-2007
On Stranger Tides (2011) https://trakt.tv/movies/pirates-of-the-caribbean-on-stranger-tides-2011
Dead Men Tell No Tales (2017) https://trakt.tv/movies/pirates-of-the-caribbean-dead-men-tell-no-tales-2017