I understand that the point of the movie is about '**letting go** of hatred and sadness which was caused by a great injustice' and it's a good message.

But doing so in a religious setting, where God is literally in front of you and can answer your questions, without addressing the question of why did God allow the injustice to occur in the first place, is impossible.

It's Ok, to 'let go' in a religious setting, where God is there but doesn't answer you directly. So you assume he has a plan or that he has some reason. Or even without it, just your faith helped you through it. But here, Mac asks God point blank "Why did you let it happen?" and there is no answer. Some mambo jumbo and evasive talk about "I'm always with you" but no actual reason, logical or otherwise.

Again, I get that the point of the movie is not to explain why God allows bad things to happen, but in this case, you can't divorce the two.
It's like a person breaks into your house, rapes, and murders your wife in front of you, and then consoles you on the virtues of 'letting go and moving forward'.

I would say it's Christain propaganda, but it seems that hardcore Christians think it's heresy to depict God as a woman.

This movie was beautiful. I laughed, I cried. For all of you out there who either believe in God or question his existence please watch this movie. It will definitely renew your faith

**If forgiving is that easily convincible, then welcome to the crime world!**

A novel based film. A religious themed film. It has a message, BUT could be a bad message for today's world. Because how the event was dealt with the story only encourages the crime, in reality. Wise people can say philosophically, morally, but not means every words practically applicable. The common people would get affected more. Other than that, I have no grudge on anything. If it has been just a fantasy and an entertaining film, excluding that Christian thing, I would have liked it better.

It was more like another 'What Dreams May Come', but less visual spectacular. On the other hand, there was an uneasiness in the development of what happened in the early stage of the story. They did not go for the detail, from the crime perspective, hence that mysterious event holds the key which we don't know exactly what happened to judge anything out of the film. So that part reminds 'The Lovely Bones'.

The story of a father whose little girl mysteriously disappeared on a camping trip. Now the struggling father to cope with the incident gets an invitation to meet the creators. His journey to the other side of the world, where he goes through a series of unexpected tests, and at the end, how his character changes are told in those remaining parts.

Worthington, Spencer, everybody was good. But the story is what I did not like. Like it was aimed for Christians only. But I believe not every Christian would agree with this story. I felt it was an unnecessary film. If it was fun like 'Bruce Almighty', the whole world would have enjoyed it. Too serious and very not acceptable message led this film to fall. No, it is not worth a watch for people with the open mind, unless this is what you were looking for.

_3/10_

As a person who doesn't believe in any sort of gods, somehow, I watched this movie.
And I have to say that I almost regretted immediately the wasted time. But not fully, and here is why.

Disclaimer: I haven't read the novel; whatever I say pertains only to the movie.
Please, do not refer to the book. This is not a review of the novel.

From the perspective of artistic value, the movie is pointless for a non-religious person.

The main point of the whole movie can be described as:
"You must forgive, no matter what happens. There is the god's plan for everything and everybody. You must believe"

And my first and last question, "Why?" remained without an answer.

And perhaps, for some people, this sounds like a relief — a consolation to keep moving forward
and live without regret for their actions and the things that happened to them and their loved ones,
no matter how bad those things were.

But I refuse to accept this kind of life stance.
I refuse to believe that our lives are already planned by someone or something else, and we cannot change anything.
I refuse to believe that we don't choose and take responsibility for our actions.
This conception deprives us of freedom because someone has already decided for us.
And it is always so easy to say that something happened because of "God works in mysterious ways" and unfortunately, many people choose this way.


But I also have to admit that this movie gave me a really good understanding of how religion works in the world.
How churches and other religious structures try to exploit people's weaknesses.
Thanks for that.


If you already agree with my position and find nothing new here,
I recommend not watching this movie and pass by