| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) | Episodes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 'Weird Al' Yankovic | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Becky Thyre | Cast | Tracy | 1 | |
 Bobcat Goldthwait | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Brendon Small | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Dana Gould | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 David Koechner | Cast | Actor | Mayor Marty Lehrman | 1 |
 Eric Zuckerman | Cast | Actor | Dad | 1 |
 Frank Birney | Cast | Actor | Old Guy | 1 |
 Frank Conniff | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Jill Talley | Cast | Actress | Self | 1 |
 Joe Bays | Cast | Actor | Johnny | 1 |
 Joel Murray | Cast | Actor | Pete | 1 |
 Kevin Meaney | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Laraine Newman | Cast | Actress | Jacqueline Waters | 1 |
 Matthew Kimbrough | Cast | Actor | Jimmy the Beef | 1 |
 Pat Asanti | Cast | Actor | Shawn | 1 |
 Paul Gregory | Cast | Actor | Judge 2016 | 1 |
 Trace Beaulieu | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Bill Parks | Cast | Actor | Dave | 1 |
 Chantal Claret | Cast | Actress | Dana | 1 |
 Travis Guba | Cast | Actor | Doorman | 1 |
 Baron Vaughn | Cast | Actor | Shane | 1 |
 Susan Burke | Cast | Actress | Witch | 1 |
 Jax Malcolm | Cast | Kid | 1 | |
Peter Xifo | Cast | Actor | Angus | 1 |
 Mike Mitchell | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Jonah Ray | Cast | Actor | Self - Host | 17 |
 Rob Gleeson | Cast | Actor | Darryl | 1 |
 Dave Anthony | Cast | Actor | Gary | 1 |
 Jeff Bryan Davis | Cast | Actor | Goodman Steve | 1 |
Mark Rivers | Cast | Chauncey | 1 | |
 Andrés du Bouchet | Cast | Jonias Raye | 1 | |
 Christie Nicholls | Cast | Actress | Goody Sarah | 1 |
Matt Dwyer | Cast | Matt | 1 | |
Deanna Rooney | Cast | Actress | Flapper | 1 |
Marquis W. Howell II | Cast | Guitar Player | 1 | |
Thomas Derrah | Cast | Store Owner | 1 | |
Todd Fasen | Cast | Actor | Harry | 1 |
Tyler Anthony Davis | Cast | Improviser | 1 | |
Alison Banowsky | Cast | Improviser | 1 | |
Alexander Niles | Cast | DJ | 1 | |
| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) | Episodes |
