| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) | Episodes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Joel McHale | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 1 |
 Loni Love | Cast | Actress | Judge | 1 |
 Maz Jobrani | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 1 |
 Tony Rock | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 1 |
 Bobby Moynihan | Cast | Actor | Judge | 1 |
 Chrishell Stause | Cast | Actress | Judge | 1 |
 Finesse Mitchell | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 1 |
 Lauren Lapkus | Cast | Actress | Herself | 1 |
 Michael Yo | Cast | Actor | Judge | 1 |
 Mikey Day | Cast | Actor | Self - Host | 24 |
 Blake Anderson | Cast | Actor | Judge | 1 |
 Dan Ahdoot | Cast | Actor | Judge | 1 |
 Jon Gabrus | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 1 |
 Arturo Castro | Cast | Actor | Judge | 1 |
 Fortune Feimster | Cast | Actress | Judge | 1 |
 Jay Pharoah | Cast | Actor | Himself | 1 |
 Rebecca Black | Cast | Actress | Judge | 1 |
 Chris Redd | Cast | Actor | Judge | 1 |
 Kirby | Cast | Actress | Judge | 1 |
 London Hughes | Cast | Herself | 1 | |
 Nico Santos | Cast | Actor | Judge | 1 |
 Chris Witaske | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 2 |
 Heidi Gardner | Cast | Actress | Judge | 1 |
 Lyric Lewis | Cast | Actress | Self - Judge | 1 |
 Karamo Brown | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 1 |
 Jason Bolden | Cast | Actor | Judge | 1 |
 Camille Kostek | Cast | Actress | Judge | 1 |
 Chloe Fineman | Cast | Actress | Judge | 1 |
 King Princess | Cast | Judge | 1 | |
 Taylor Tomlinson | Cast | Actress | Self - Judge | 1 |
 Courtney Parchman | Cast | Judge | 1 | |
 Brittany Broski | Cast | Actress | Judge | 1 |
Daym Drops | Cast | Self - Judge | 1 | |
 Hester Sunshine | Cast | Actress | Self - Judge | 1 |
Ronnie Woo | Cast | Judge | 1 | |
| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) | Episodes |
