Ok so, I had no idea what to expect from this going in. Turns out, I had found a show that was enjoyable to watch and hate at the same time. It's generic as a slasher can get. But they do a great job at making you hate the right people. This is the case in both seasons, but sadly season two fell so far down.
The Executioner was an ok season at the start, then leads to disarray by the end. Had likeable characters and had some good kills. But when I got to watching Guilty Party, from the very start I could tell this wasn't going to be the same. I was all for that in changing up the formula, but it leads to a disappointing and annoying season I trudged through quickly to finish.

Overview:

The Executioner: 5.5/10
- It was a fun season that I looked forward to seeing the ending.
- It had fun characters all of which had unique personalities.
- Made you feel for all deaths either being sad or happy about it.
- The story was lacking a heap in terms of tension and realism.

Guilty Party: 2.5/10
- This season is boring, bland, and annoying.
- The characters are almost unbearable to watch beside a few that are ok at certain moments.
- The premise of this season makes you dislike the main group straight away, leading to no hope for survival.
- The kills are good in this season as well but lack believability somewhat for a few. Ups the gore a bit from season one.