Ok.. Let me make this a short one: this show is decent, has potential and a twist. But it's annoyingly over-dramatized. It quickly becomes old and thank god it's only 7 episodes.

When you know the true story, this is too over dramatized and over the top…my eyes were rolling by episode 2

I enjoyed it. It's not spectacular and has a bit of the 'american horror story' atmosphere, but lighter. There is a good cast there, but their talents weren't fully utilized.

Honestly, skip this and just watch the Buzzfeed Unsolved episode.

9/10
Superb
I am glad I WATCHED this
as I am absolutely fascinated with the real life case. Yes the family had their name changed for this show and they never actually moved into the house.
So all the rest of the show apart from the
letters was a full on dramatisation.
I was cool with that because what we got was one Hella of an unsolved mystery based on a true event that is such a creepy scary situation that it carried the who show no matter how much was changed are added.
The acting was strong the mystery is frickin awesome and the show as a hole was superb and in the near future I will Definitely be
"WATCHING"
it again.

VERDICT: LOVED IT

i went back and forth a lot while watching on whether or not i thought it was good. i thought it was extremely cheesy in the beginning, but towards the middle, i started to suspend my belief a little bit and i was totally enjoying it! since it's based on a true story that remains unsolved in real life, i thought they were going to make the decision to solve it in the show? especially since they fabricated SO many other elements? super disappointed with the ending

Jennifer Coolidge just makes every show better. Cast is solid, it's just overly dramatized like others have noted. Dialogues aren't great. The setting doesn't work for the mystery they were going for. I also think it drags on a bit longer than it should have. I was bored pretty easily, just wanted to finish it. Would not recommend.

Believe the imdb and trakt ratings, and follow my advice: don't waste your time. The series look good and is well acted, but who cares if the plot is that bad. Couple receives mean letters after buying a beautiful suburban home and for the next 6 hours, the series will try to make you believe that the author of the letters can be anyone out of the gallery of unlikeable characters around, in the most convoluted ways, with the dumbest plot twist. If this is your idea of fun go for it! I warned you.

Only watched this for Jennifer Coolidge and even she wasn’t enough for me to enjoy this.

Pretty good show. During the first episode I thought it was going to go down the haunted house/demonic crap, but it isn't. I would also have bolted the basement door from the outside after the first incident, but that's just me. I'd also have punched the nosey neighbours on the nose for coming onto my property and threatening me... I'm not a violent individual, but that's what I'd have done.

Just a big ugly house IMO. Anyway, the show had some moments, but it's more a spoof than a mystery. Pretty average fair.
PS Just read it was actually a true and scary story ... this seemed more like a comedy to me ... opps!

1. Every character in this show is so unlikeable, but Dean most of all, so whenever someone would butt heads with him they came off looking better by comparison. But Theodora was pretty cool, so, points for that I guess.

2. They really missed out on a chance to make the show marginally by not having Ryan Bergara read The Watcher's letters.

3. Pretty sure the moral of the story is that rich people be crazy, and bring their stupid problems on by being garbage rich people.

The main male actor was a horrible casting choice in my opinion.

Dumb, bad, and ultimately disappointing. just be warned ahead of time that this is an unsolved case. sincerely not worth watching, unless you want to riff on it and rip into how truly incomprehensibly stupid this show is. Ryan Murphy has officially lost his touch, I'm no longer interested in projects whose only merit is 'produced by Ryan Murphy.' I'm out

I was watching the first episode and the tone was weird. When searching the show I thought I'd find comedy being one of the genres. No, but then I saw it: "Ryan Murphy". Of course. I could just feel the awful "horror" tone of Murphy. I only finished episode 1 so I'd know not to try it again. I would never have tried the show if I knew Ryan Murphy was behind it.

I've hated and never finished most of AHS seasons. 1/2/5 were good and Coven was ok. The rest of AHS I dropped after one episode.

Thought this was a comedy but it wasn't even funny. The story line was poor, acting was bad, and the mystery was just plain boring. The ending was basically a set up for another season and honestly I don't think that anyone will watch it unless they need a filler show they can put on while doing something else.

[Netflix[ A strange true story that the screenwriters take care to make especially messy, possibly because the true events were never resolved. But it didn't take 5 and a half hours to tell it, so continuous turns are created that, in most cases, lead nowhere. The endemic problem of the so called prestige tv, dragging it all out until it is no longer possible to find any more skeins to unwind.

More drama then true story. It was struggle to get thru after 3 episodes

As an adult survivor of the trauma of living in the suburbs, I particularly delight in watching series and movies in which clueless characters move into a suburban neighborhood with high hopes for happiness, only to encounter instead a haunted house, a sketchy history, nightmare neighbors, or in the case of Netflix's The Watcher, all of the above. Rich assholes Nora and Dean are rather dull, (played by Naomi Watts and Bobby Cannavale, aided by co-stars Naomi's glasses and Bobby's eyebrows) but it's the performances of the supporting cast where the real magic happens on the smaller screen. Jennifer Coolidge as a ruthless realtor is especially sinister, and neighbor Mia Farrow is delightfully creepy; ten bucks says that your hair will surely stand on end when she screeches, "NOT very neighborly!" Noma Dumezweni as an amateur sleuth is by far one of the most captivating players in this ensemble, and her driving gloves and UK accent will make you shiver with antici...pation . I keep wanting to quit Netflix, but a series like this makes a real "dumbwaiter " out of me. Watch the show, and you'll get it.

Unsettling but in a good suspenseful way. Liked this! Wish the ending was better though for that poor family.

A good physiatrics thriller that has the viewer's though process all over; is it a ghost, is it this person or this person, could it be something else???? However, just when you thought the mystery is going to get solved there is another turn of events and it all seems to get unraveled again with not much progress. Yes, a bit disappointing ending, but hopefully this is no the end. But, regardless of that and some poor acting, this was certainly a edge of your seat series with great plot twists and character development and genre development, as sometimes it seems like a thriller and sometimes you might think its going to be a slasher.