Type in any movie or show to find where you can watch it, or type a person's name.

User Reviews for: Scorpion

huntrckr
10/10  10 years ago
While I respect other people's opinions about the accuracy and stupid plot holes (pilot ep, not landing the plane manually, etc)... This is a Hollywood entertainment show, with the emphasis on entertainment.

So,
a) you have to create a crisis
b) you have to make up situations that create drama and suspense
c) it needs to be exciting

If you went down the road of technically correct and 100% realistic, you might as well call it a documentary and cancel the show... because 90% of TV watching people want entertainment and suspense, not realism.

I find myself in the following situation. I can call BS on 90% of the stuff in the show, much like pretty much every other successful show(CSI, Fringe, Mentalist, etc) but I don't. It's not SUPPOSE to be real.

The reality of Airport control software and how a failure would be handled is boring in real life.
The reality of how a biological attack on a senators daughter would be handled is boring to the point of tears
The reality of bringing down the Internet, and getting rid of all evidence of an e-mail contents would equally be dull as watching paint dry.

I much prefer suspending disbelief (like we do when we watch sci-fi series) and simply enjoying the suspense, action and FICTIONAL plot which does not have to make sense. If that's not something you are capable of, then this show might not be the right fit for you.
Like  -  Dislike  -  22
Please use spoiler tags:[spoiler] text [/spoiler]
Reply by drumnugget
10 years ago
Wow. George Orwell would have a field day having you around I'm sure: I have never read such a complicit, "I will obey and suspend my entire thought process", review, as yours. I'm glad YOU enjoy it, but, it makes no sense to try and demand other people should do the same.<br /> <br /> You might be able to switch off your beliefs, suspend your criticism and you might not find stupid plots, strange character behaviour, and impossible stories annoying. But many people, including me, do. In fact, it's insulting the viewer's intelligence, and if that's not bad enough already, here comes mr. or mrs. Gladly Obey, telling us to shut up.<br /> <br /> Astounding to say the least, and your review is the most insulting review I have read on Trakt so far, so, at least you have that going for you. In light of that, it's typical how you start your comment by saying "I respect other people's opinions" because, obviously, you don't.
Reply  -  Like  -  Deslike  -  10

Please use spoiler tags:[spoiler] text [/spoiler]
Reply by ds1
10 years ago
Sadly, replies can't be liked on trakt, I'd really want to like drumnugget's reply. :'(<br /> <br /> Someone got the definition and meaning of suspension of disbelief very wrong.<br /> It doesn't apply on plots that make no sense, by the way. With or without suspension of disbelief such plots still make no sense.<br /> With the presented logic you could dismiss every valid criticism towards any show no matter how bad it is. Resulting in no improvments ever.<br /> However, plots really have to make sense, even in fiction, at least in the presented universe.<br /> <br /> To be honest, your post comes off as very shortsighted, ignorant and condescending.
Reply  -  Like  -  Deslike  -  00

Please use spoiler tags:[spoiler] text [/spoiler]
Back to Top