She's Making a List (2025)

Holiday romance meets whimsical fantasy; perfect for fans of heartwarming Christmas tales like "The Christmas Chronicles." Non-romantics, beware!

Genres: Romance, Comedy, TV Movie

Cast

  • Cast member 1
  • Cast member 2
  • Cast member 3
  • Cast member 4
  • Cast member 5
  • Cast member 6
  • Cast member 7
  • Cast member 8
  • Cast member 9
  • Cast member 10

Your Status

She's Making a List

Movie20251h 24mEnglishRomance, Comedy, TV Movie
6.4
User Score
IMDb

Where to Watch

subscription

Hallmark Movies Now (Via Amazon Pri
fuboTV
Hallmark Movies Now

Overview

A by-the-book holiday inspector is sent to evaluate an 11-year-old’s behavior for a famous seasonal list. When she grows close to the child’s widowed parent, her strict workplace rules and data-driven approach start to clash with real-life feelings as Christmas draws near.

Insights

Review Summary

Pros: cozy Christmas vibes; playful fantasy premise; light holiday humor | Cons: slow start; uneven chemistry; predictable, thin story

Will You Like This?

You’ll likely enjoy this if you want a cozy, slightly quirky holiday romance with a magical “naughty or nice” twist, similar in vibe to Christmas with the Darlings or Love, Classified; Not for you if you dislike slow starts, fourth-wall narration, or very silly premises.

My Friends' Ratings

None of your friends have rated this yet.

Featured Comments/Tips

Lacey Chabert is on the case in _She’s Making a List_. When a Naughty-or-Nice inspector gets involved in the life of a young girl that she’s assigned to evaluate, she starts to question the whole naughty or nice system. Chabert gives a strong performance and has good chemistry with co-star Andrew Walker. And the film uses a clever narrative device of having Chabert break the fourth wall to explain to the audience how she does her job and how the naughty or nice system works. However, the plot kind of falls apart in the last act and doesn’t tie up the various subplots very well. Still, the comedy’s rather fun and delivers some good laughs. _She’s Making a List_ is entertaining, but it has some problems that hold it back.

Lacey Chabert is on the case in _She’s Making a List_. When a Naughty-or-Nice inspector gets involved in the life of a young girl that she’s assigned to evaluate, she starts to question the whole naughty or nice system. Chabert gives a strong performance and has good chemistry with co-star Andrew Walker. And the film uses a clever narrative device of having Chabert break the fourth wall to explain to the audience how she does her job and how the naughty or nice system works. However, the plot kind of falls apart in the last act and doesn’t tie up the subplots very well. Still, the comedy’s rather fun and delivers some good laughs. _She’s Making a List_ is entertaining, but it has some problems that hold it back.

Featured User Reviews

None of your fellow watchers have a review yet.

Leave a Comment/Tip

140 characters remaining

Write a Review

10000 characters remaining

Set Alert

We'll notify you when She's Making a List becomes available on:

Report an Issue

What's wrong with this page?

Create New List

0/125 characters (minimum 5)

Examples:

  • Sci-Fi Classics
  • Date Night Movies
  • Shows to Watch with Kids
  • Award Winners

She's Making a List Poster

100%
She's Making a List Poster

Available in 0 Countries

Loading

...